STATE LAWS     CASE LAW / LITIGATION ABBOTT PRESCHOOL PROGRAM RESEARCH / EXPERTS RESOURCES
 

Kentucky
 
State Preschool Program

Overview


Kentucky requires all school districts to offer a half-day preschool program to every four-year-old child who meets the eligibility standard for the federal free lunch program and all three- and four-year-olds with developmental delays and disabilities, regardless of income. Districts are also allowed to serve other four-year-olds if space is available. According to the National Institute for Early Education Research (NIEER), Kentucky served 29% of all four-year-olds in its preschool program in 2006-2007. Although state funding for the preschool program had been decreasing since 2001, it remained level for FY 2006, and an additional $23.5 million a year was appropriated for FY 2007 and FY 2008 to expand eligibility to four-year-olds from families earning up to 150% of the federal poverty level. This additional funding increased per child spending from $2,496 in 2006 to $3,474 in 2007, and lifted total annual preschool spending to $75.1 million.

State Policy

While there are no specific statutory provisions that affirm the importance of state-funded preschool, the existence of a high quality program for low-income children is indicative of the fact that the State recognizes the vital role early childhood education plays for at-risk children. Furthermore, the Department of Education's Early Childhood Standards note that high quality early education programs are "the foundation for an expectation of high level outcomes for young children."  

Eligibility Criteria

Kentucky’s preschool program is targeted to very low-income children. Beginning with the 2006-2007 school year, all four-year-olds with a family income at or below 150% of the federal poverty level, are covered. The program also serves three- and four-year-old children with developmental delays and disabilities, as defined by federal special education law. School districts are required to “establish and maintain an active recruitment process which systematically assures enrollment of eligible children.” Other four-year-olds may attend a district’s preschool program if placement is available.

Program Length/Duration

The program runs on an academic calendar year and is a half-day schedule that must provide a minimum of 2 ½ hours of classroom time per day.

Funding

Funding is through a grant allotment system whereby the Department of Education allocates funds to individual school districts based on the number of eligible children in the district. The Department determines the per child allotment for each year. These funds must remain separate from all other district funds, and their use is limited to implementation of the preschool program. 

Quality Standards

In a national survey of quality standards, the National Institute for Early Education Research (NIEER) gave Kentucky's preschool program a rating of 8 out of 10. There is a maximum class size of 20, a staff-child ratio of 1:10, and provisions regarding family support services, health screening, social service referrals, and nutrition and facilities requirements. The teacher degree requirements require a bachelor's degree as well as an early childhood education certificate, except where waivers are granted to teachers already in preschool teaching positions. Assistant teachers only need a high school diploma, falling short of NIEER’s requirement for a CDA or an equivalent degree or certification. Kentucky also fails to meet NIEER’s benchmark for monitoring, since site visits are not required.

The Kentucky administrative regulations include broad curriculum guidelines, and the Department of Education has adopted comprehensive early learning standards for three- and four-year-olds that meet NIEER’s benchmark.

Delivery of Preschool Services

The Kentucky Preschool Program is operated primarily through public school districts, although individual districts may subcontract with private schools, community agencies, Head Start centers or childcare centers to provide preschool services. Any nonpublic program must meet all of the other standards for the preschool program and must be approved by the Kentucky Board of Education. Any private program must be separately incorporated from any related religious institution and must not offer a religious curriculum. The statute also requires local districts to work with existing preschool programs to avoid duplication of programs and services, to avoid supplanting federal funds, and specifically to maximize Head Start funds.

Requirements for Student Assessment and Program Evaluation

Kentucky provides that students should be assessed on an ongoing and regular basis. Administrative regulations require local programs be evaluated at least annually. The evaluation must include rate of participation, parental satisfaction, future success of participating children, and adherence to state administrative regulations.

Legal Framework

Education Clause in State Constitution

The education clause in the Kentucky Constitution provides, "the General Assembly shall, by appropriate legislation, provide for an efficient system of common schools throughout the State." 

Summary of Case Law on School Finance System

In Rose v. Council for Better Education the Kentucky Supreme Court held that  "[a] child's right to an adequate education is a fundamental one under our Constitution."  The Court found that the state's common school system did not satisfy the constitutional requirement that the General Assembly provide an efficient system of common schools throughout state. The Court held that to meet the constitutional mandate, the system of education must be adequately funded to achieve its goals and substantially uniform throughout the state, so that every child in the state is provided with an equal opportunity to have an adequate education.

The Court in Rose laid out seven capacities that must be the goal for every child under a constitutionally "efficient" system of education: (i) sufficient oral and written communication skills to enable students to function in a complex and rapidly changing civilization; (ii) sufficient knowledge of economic, social, and political systems to enable the student to make informed choices; (iii) sufficient understanding of governmental processes to enable the student to understand the issues that affect his or her community, state, and nation; (iv) sufficient self-knowledge and knowledge of his or her mental and physical wellness; (v) sufficient grounding in the arts to enable each student to appreciate his or her cultural and historical heritage; (vi) sufficient training or preparation for advanced training in either academic or vocational fields so as to enable each child to choose and pursue life work intelligently; and (vii) sufficient levels of academic or vocational skills to enable public school students to compete favorably with their counterparts in surrounding states, in academics or in the job market.  Other state courts around the country have cited the Rose decision and these seven capabilities in their discussion of a constitutionally adequate education under their state constitution.

In 2003, two cases were filed that challenge Kentucky's current system of school finance on adequacy and equity grounds, consolidated under the caption Young v. Williams. The cases were dismissed on summary judgment in February 2007, based on the trial court’s determination that the funding system was not arbitrary, and educational appropriations were sufficiently adequate to cause performance improvements in the public schools of Kentucky.

Summary of Case Law on Preschool

There have yet to be any decisions on preschool education in Kentucky. However, the plaintiiffs in the school finance case, Young v. Williams, dismissed on summary judgment, had included a claim for more state funding for preschool education.

Constitutional Provisions on Public Education

 Ky. Const. § 183

The General Assembly shall, by appropriate legislation, provide for an efficient system of common schools throughout the State.

Case Law on the Right to Public Education and Preschool

Is Education a Fundamental Right under the State Constitution?

"The framers of Section 183 emphasized that education is essential to the welfare of the citizens of the Commonwealth. By this animus to Section 183, we recognize that education is a fundamental right in Kentucky."  Rose v. Council for Better Education, 790 S.W.2d 186, 206 (Ky. 1989).

"A child's right to an adequate education is a fundamental one under our Constitution."  Id. at 212.

School Finance Cases in Favor of Plaintiffs: 

Rose v. Council for Better Education, 790 S.W.2d 186 (Ky. 1989)


The Kentucky Supreme Court held that the state's common school system, characterized by overall inadequacy when compared to national standards and standards of adjacent states, great disparity in educational opportunities throughout the state, and great disparity and inadequacy of financial support throughout the state, did not satisfy the constitutional requirement that the General Assembly provide an efficient system of common schools throughout state.  The Court defined an efficient system of education as one that has as its goal providing every child with at least seven stated capacities, discussed below under "State Court Standard for a Constitutionally Adequate Education. " The Court held that to meet the constitutional mandate, the system of education must be adequately funded to achieve its goals and substantially uniform throughout the state, so that every child in the state is provided with an equal opportunity to have an adequate education. 

Standard for a Constitutionally Adequate Education: 

Rose v. Council for Better Education, 790 S.W.2d 186, 212 (Ky. 1989)


"[A]n efficient system of education must have as its goal to provide each and every child with at least the seven following capacities:
  (i) sufficient oral and written communication skills to enable students to function in a complex and rapidly changing civilization; (ii) sufficient knowledge of economic, social, and political systems to enable the student to make informed choices; (iii) sufficient understanding of governmental processes to enable the student to understand the issues that affect his or her community, state, and nation; (iv) sufficient self-knowledge and knowledge of his or her mental and physical wellness; (v) sufficient grounding in the arts to enable each student to appreciate his or her cultural and historical heritage; (vi) sufficient training or preparation for advanced training in either academic or vocational fields so as to enable each child to choose and pursue life work intelligently; and (vii) sufficient levels of academic or vocational skills to enable public school students to compete favorably with their counterparts in surrounding states, in academics or in the job market."

School Finance Cases against Plaintiffs:

Young v. Williams, Franklin County Cir. Court (consolidated action: Council for Better Education v. Williams and Young v. Williams) (2007)

These cases were filed in 2003, challenging the state's current system of school finance on adequacy and equity grounds. Plaintiffs had included a claim for more state funding for preschool education in the suit. (Funding for Kentucky's preschool program had been cut 21% over a three year period.) On cross-motions for summary judgment, the trial court dismissed the entire case, but agreed that "more funding for education is a good idea" and "education should be the legislature’s exclusive first priority." Following an unsuccessful motion for reconsideration, plaintiffs decided not to appeal.

The plaintiffs had alleged that five costing-out studies (commissioned by plaintiffs and the state) determined that Kentucky underfunded its schools between $1.08 and $2.2 billion for the 2003-2004 school year, rendering the state’s financing scheme inadequate. Plaintiffs also alleged the financing scheme was arbitrary, since the state failed to use a specific, systematic method of quantifying the necessary costs of an adequate education. The defendants offered evidence that Kentucky students had nevertheless shown dramatic performance improvements. Because the plaintiffs relied on cost studies, which relate to the adequacy of inputs, and the court found no proof of diminished educational outputs—student performance or school system adequacy—the court dismissed the adequacy claim. The court also found that the separation of powers doctrine prevented it from substituting its judgment for the legislature’s as to what the proper method for determining educational appropriations should be. The court could not find that the legislature’s method was arbitrary, since the educational outputs of the school system were showing improvement, according to the state.

Decisions Ruling School Finance Issues Were Non-Justiciable:

None.

Cases Related to State-Funded Preschool:

None.

Pending School Finance Cases:

None.

Statutes, Regulations and Guidance Documents on State Preschool Program

Kentucky Revised Statutes (K.R.S.) § 157.3175, Preschool education program

Kentucky Revised Statutes (K.R.S.) § 158.100, Programs required to be provided by school district

Fiscal Biennium 2006-2008 Budget Modification Report

702 Kentucky Administrative Rules (K.A.R.) § 3:250, Preschool grant allocations.

704 Kentucky Administrative Rules (K.A.R.) § 3:410, Preschool Education Program for four year old children

704 Kentucky Administrative Rules (K.A.R.) § 3:420, Preschool associate teachers

Kentucky's Early Childhood Standards

Provisions Expressing State Policy on Preschool:

There are no statutory or regulatory provisions specifically acknowledging the importance of early childhood education, although Kentucky has served low-income 4-year-olds in its state-funded preschool program since 1990.  The Kentucky Department of Education recognized the importance of high quality preschool programs in the introduction section of the state's Early Childhood Standards:

High quality early care and education programs are the foundation for an expectation of high level outcomes for young children.  Research has shown that children participating in quality early care and education programs demonstrate better math and language skills, possess increased attention and social skills, and have fewer behavioral problems in elementary school than other children.

Eligibility Criteria for State Preschool Program:

K.R.S. § 157.3175 

(
1) [I]t shall be the responsibility of each local school district to assure that a developmentally appropriate half-day preschool education program is provided for each child who is four (4) years of age by October 1 of each year and at risk of educational failure [and] . . .  [a]ll other four (4) year old children
shall be served to the extent placements are available. . . .

... (3) Children who are at risk shall be identified based on the Federal School Lunch Program eligibility criteria for free lunch. . . .  

(6) Programs shall reflect an equitable geographic distribution representative of all areas of the Commonwealth.

Fiscal Biennium 2006-2008 Budget Modification Report

The Senate provides additional General Fund support totaling $23,502,300 in each fiscal year to provide Preschool services to children in families up to 150% of the federal poverty guideline.

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.

Section 2.  Eligibility. (1) Except as provided in subsection (2) of this section, a child shall be eligible for enrollment in the preschool program if the child is:

   (a) A resident of the district;

   (b) Four (4) years old by October 1 of the school year; and

   (c) Approved for free lunch based on federal free lunch criteria in effect as of the child's initial day of attendance in preschool. Preschool eligibility may be determined up to four (4) months prior to the start of school. Once free lunch eligibility has been approved, the child shall remain eligible for enrollment in the preschool program for the remainder of the school year.

   (2) A resident child who is four (4) years old by October 1 but who is not eligible for the free lunch program may be served if space is available.

Program Length/Duration:

K.R.S. § 157.3175.

 (1) [I]t shall be the responsibility of each local school district to assure that a developmentally appropriate half-day preschool education program is provided. ...

704  K.A.R. § 3:410

Section 6.  Program Operation.  

(1) The local school district shall select one (1) of the following program options:

   (a) Standard half-day, five (5) day a week program (single session);

   (b) Half-day, four (4) day a week program in single or double session, with the fifth day for services to children and their families, such as home visits, special experiences for children, parent training, or coordination of medical or social services; or

   (c) A locally-designed program approved by the chief state school officer.

(2) If a double session program is utilized, the following provisions shall be made:

   (a) Time shall be allotted prior to each session to allow staff to prepare for the session as well as give individual attention to children entering and leaving the program;

   (b) Adequate break time shall be provided for staff during the course of the day;

   (c) Staff assignments shall provide time for parent involvement activities and coordination of services described in subsections (5) through (8) of this section . . . .  

(3) The hours of operation of the half-day program may vary but shall provide a minimum of two and one-half (2 1/2) hours of classroom time per day, which shall not include the time required to provide breakfast or lunch. The program shall provide direct services for children or parents for the minimum number of teaching days set by the local school district for the school year.

Scope of State’s Responsibility to Provide Preschool:

K.R.S. § 157.3175 (1).

[I]t shall be the responsibility of each local school district to assure that a developmentally appropriate half-day preschool education program is provided for each child who is four (4) years of age by October 1 of each year and at risk of educational failure. . . . All other four (4) year old children shall be served to the extent placements are available. 

K.R.S. § 158.100.

Notwithstanding any statute to the contrary, each school district shall provide an approved preschool school program.  An approved preschool school program . . . shall be provided for the children residing in the district by maintaining schools. . . . 

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.
  

Section 3.  Grant Allocation System.  (1) A local school district shall submit a proposal to the Kentucky Department of Education to operate or oversee the operation of a developmentally appropriate preschool education program for eligible children. . .

Scope of State's Responsibility to Fund Preschool:

K.R.S. § 157.3175(3).

Funds appropriated by the General Assembly for the preschool education programs shall be granted to local school districts according to a grant allotment system approved by the Kentucky Board of Education. . . . Appropriations shall be separate from all other funds appropriated to the Department of Education.

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.

Section 3. Grant Allocation System. (1) A local school district shall submit a proposal to the Kentucky Department of Education to operate or oversee the operation of a developmentally appropriate preschool education program for eligible children. Each proposal shall include the requirements set forth in KRS 157.3175(5).

(2) Funding for districts shall be based on the preschool grant allocation system established in 702 KAR 3:250.

702 K.A.R. § 3:250. 

Section 1.
  Preschool Programs. For the purposes of this administrative regulation, the term "preschool programs" refers to the two (2) educational programs established in the
KRS 157.226 and 157.3175 for children below primary school age; the preschool program for handicapped children and the preschool education program for four (4) year old children.  

Section 2. Funding Eligibility.

   (1) Children eligible to be counted for funding purposes for the preschool program for four (4) year old children shall include only those children who are at risk of educational failure and who meet the criteria set forth in 704 KAR 3:410, Section 1(1).

   (2) Children eligible to be counted for funding purposes for the preschool program for handicapped children shall include only those children who meet the criteria set forth in 707 KAR 1:150, Section 1(2).

   (3) A child who meets the eligibility criteria under both subsections (1) and (2) of this section shall be included in only one (1) of these two (2) groups for purposes of generating funds under these preschool programs.

   (4) Eligible children who are enrolled by parent choice in other preschool programs providing nonsupplemental educational services through state or federal funds at no cost to parents shall not be included in the count of eligible children used to generate funds under these preschool programs.

Section 3. Enrollment Data.  

  (1) Funds for districts shall be allotted based on the number of eligible children as defined in Section 2 of this administrative regulation who are enrolled in the district's
preschool programs on December 1 of the previous year. Program funding shall be adjusted proportionately when the enrollment on December 1 of the current year is more than five (5) percent above or below the number of children served on December 1 of the previous year.

   (2) If there are available funds after districts have been allotted funds to serve all eligible enrolled children through the state funds appropriated, then the remaining funds may be prorated to those districts that transport eligible children who are enrolled in Head Start, up to the amount per child allowed for transportation in Section 5 of this administrative regulation.

Section 4. Use of Funds.

  (1) Appropriations to the local school district for the
preschool programs shall be separate and apart from all other funds appropriated to the local school district.

   (2) Use of the funds appropriated for the preschool programs shall be limited to activities for the implementation of these programs, pursuant to 704 KAR 3:410, 707 KAR 1:150, and the district's application for the preschool programs.
  
Section 5. Formula.

   (1) The Department of Education shall annually recommend a
preschool allocation formula to the State Board for Elementary and Secondary Education for review and approval. The allocation formula shall specify the amount of funds to be allocated for each eligible child.

   (2) If the state funds appropriated are not sufficient, the funding formula shall be adjusted proportionately.

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.
   

Section 3. Grant Allocation System.

   . . . (2) Funding for districts shall be based on the preschool grant allocation system established in 702 K.A.R. § 3:250.

Source of Funding for Preschool Program:

K.R.S. § 157.3175(3).

Funds appropriated by the General Assembly for the preschool education programs shall be granted to local school districts according to a grant allotment system approved by the Kentucky Board of Education. . . . Appropriations shall be separate from all other funds appropriated to the Department of Education.

Fiscal Biennium 2006-2008 Budget Modification Report

The Senate provides additional General Fund support totaling $23,502,300 in each fiscal year to provide Preschool services to children in families up to 150% of the federal poverty guideline.

Scope of Child's Right to Attend Preschool:

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.   

Section 5.  Enrollment. (1) Enrollment of a child in the preschool program shall be at the discretion of the parent or legal guardian. Each local school district shall establish and maintain an active recruitment process which systematically assures enrollment of eligible children. This process shall be outlined in a written plan which includes procedures for:


   (a) Notification of the right to participate, presented in the parent's primary language or natural mode of communication;

   (b) Identification of all eligible children regardless of race, sex, creed, color, national origin or handicapping condition;

   (c) Written documentation to demonstrate that emphasis has been given to recruiting those eligible children not currently served by a preschool program; and

   (d) Contact to agencies and programs serving local preschool children or their families to encourage participation in the recruitment process, taking into account the demographic makeup of the community and the needs of the children and their families.

Curriculum Content Standards for Preschool Program:

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.   

Section 6.  Program Operation.  

  . . . (9) The preschool program shall include developmentally appropriate experiences in cognitive, communication, social, physical, and emotional development as well as creative expression. The preschool program shall assist young children with their intrapersonal and interpersonal skills and in maximizing self-management and independence. The program shall include appropriate learning activities and teaching techniques in accordance with each child's level of comprehension and maturation.


   (10) The program shall provide a supportive social and emotional climate which:

   (a) Enhances children's understanding of themselves as individuals, and in relation to others, by providing for individual, small group, and large group activities;

   (b) Gives children many opportunities for success through developmentally appropriate program activities; and

   (c) Provides an environment of acceptance which helps each child develop a positive self-concept, enhance his or her individual strengths, build ethnic pride, and facilitate social relationships.

   (11) The program shall promote the development of intellectual skills by:

   (a) Encouraging children to solve problems, initiate activities, explore, experiment, question, and gain mastery through learning by doing (concrete experiential learning);

   (b) Promoting language understanding and use in an atmosphere that encourages each communication among children and between children and adults;

   (c) Utilizing a curriculum in which a variety of skills are integrated into activities targeted toward the interests of children;

   (d) Encouraging children to organize their experiences and understand concepts;

   (e) Utilizing a language experience approach to introduce printed materials according to the individual developmental level of the child; and

   (f) Providing a daily balance of activities in the following dimensions:

   1. Indoor and outdoor;

   2. Quiet and active;

   3. Individual and group;

   4. Large and small groups;

   5. Child and staff initiated; and

   6. Structured and spontaneous.

   (12) The program shall promote physical growth by:

   . . . (b) Providing developmentally appropriate materials and equipment, in sufficient quantity to allow choice, and providing supervised time for children to use large and small muscles to increase their physical skills;

   (c) Providing appropriate guidance while children use equipment and materials which promote children's physical growth;

   . . . (e) Providing developmentally appropriate information regarding nutrition, involving children as feasible in the planning and preparation of snacks and meals, and providing appropriate supervision during meals to develop language, understanding and problem-solving skills; and

   (f) Providing developmentally appropriate information about health as an integral part of program activities.

   (13) The program shall promote social skills and social interactions by:

   (a) Providing positive guidance with consistent, clear rules presented in developmentally appropriate ways; and

   (b) Providing positive adult and peer role models, focusing on the level of the child.

   (14) The program shall be individualized to meet the special needs of children by:

   (a) Having a curriculum which is relevant and reflective of the needs of the population served (such as, bilingual or bicultural, multicultural, rural, urban, or migrant) . . . .

   . . . (20) The preschool program shall provide developmentally appropriate instruction to children regarding safety procedures, such as riding the bus and emergency procedures.

Building a Strong Foundation for School Success: Kentucky's Early Childhood Standards (January 2006)

Sample:

Math Standard 1: Demonstrates competence in skills and concepts of mathematics

Benchmark 1.3: Uses the attributes of objects for comparison and patterning

Developmental Continuum:

Matches objects.

Example Behaviors:

1. Edie matches a red bead to a picture of a red bead.

2. RaShonda fits the circle and the triangle into the form board.

3. Natalie put the shapes in the shape sorter.

Teacher Certification/Qualification Standards for Preschool Program: 

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.


Section 7. Personnel.  

(1) Instructional staff in the preschool shall include the following types of personnel:


   (a) A lead teacher who meets the following qualifications:

   1. Beginning with the 2002-2003 school year, a person who holds a certificate or statement of eligibility for a certificate in interdisciplinary early childhood education, or has been exempted by the Kentucky Education Professional Standards Board from additional certification in order to continue teaching in an early childhood position. A school district may request approval from the Department of Education to use as the instructional lead a person who meets the preschool associate teacher qualifications and who has been employed prior to school year 2004-2005 to perform paraprofessional instructional duties pursuant to 704 KAR 3:420 . . . .

   . . . 3. If a person who meets the qualifications established in subparagraph 1 . . . of this paragraph is not available, a local board may develop a training plan in early childhood education and request approval for an individual with a minimum of one (1) year of early childhood training or experience and a degree in family studles, social work, psychology, nursing, or other related area, including education if not specified under subparagraph 1 . . . of this paragraph.

   4. A local board may request approval for a person who meets the preschool associate teacher qualifications to perform paraprofessional instructional duties pursuant to 704 K.A.R. § 3:420; and

   (b) A teaching assistant who is an instructional aide.

   (2) A preschool classroom shall have at least one (1) lead teacher. A teaching assistant or other professional personnel shall be used in addition to the lead teacher to provide an appropriate adult-child ratio in each classroom, pursuant to Section 6(4) of this administrative regulation. A lead teacher shall provide instructional services to a maximum of twenty (20) children, within the parameters of subsection (4) of this section.

   (3) A lead teacher shall be responsible for organizing the classroom, providing a developmentally appropriate curriculum, and supervising and assigning the activities of teaching assistants, student helpers, and other noncertified staff in the preschool class. A lead teacher shall be responsible for at least the following parental activities, described in Section 6(5) of this administrative regulation:

   (a) Parent participation in the classroom;

   (b) Parent-teacher conferences; and

   (c) A minimum of two (2) home visits per child per year.

   (4) A local school district shall assign professional staff, including the lead teacher, to conduct parental involvement activities and coordination with health and social services, pursuant to Section 6(5) through (8) of this administrative regulation. A lead teacher who has been assigned coordination responsibilities related to parent involvement activities and health and social services and who operates double sessions shall be considered to be going beyond responsibilities set out in subsection (3) of this section and shall provide services to a maximum of thirty-four (34) children total, within the adult-child ratio per classroom established in Section 6(4) of this administrative regulation.

   (5) A lead teacher shall participate in the required number of professional development days applicable to certified personnel in the local school district. A teaching assistant shall participate annually in a minimum of eighteen (18) hours of professional development. Professional development activities shall be related to the nature and needs of young children and their families, including those with special needs. Records shall be kept for all personnel documenting participation in professional development training.

   (6) At all times, a program shall have a staff person on the premises who is trained in emergency first aid and cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).

704 K.A.R. § 3:420.

   Section 3. Qualifications. (1) A preschool associate teacher shall hold one (1) of the following or its equivalent as approved by the Department of Education:

   (a) An associate degree with a professional core of courses in early childhood education or child development;

   (b) A child development associate certificate conferred by the Council for Early Childhood Professional Recognition; or

   (c) A Kentucky vocational diploma for preschool teacher.

   (2) A local board may request approval of a preschool associate teacher who has begun and is in the process of completing a degree, diploma or certificate specified in subsection (1) of this section.

   (3) Curriculum oversight shall be provided by an individual who meets one (1) of the following criteria:

   (a) Holds certification or a statement of eligibility for interdisciplinary early childhood education;

   (b) Has been exempted by the Kentucky Education Professional Standards Board from additional certification in order to continue teaching in an early childhood position;

   (c) Provided supervision to a preschool Level III teachers under the interim requirements in 704 KAR 3:410 prior to the 1999-2000 school year; or

   (d) Is qualified to serve on an internship team for interns in Interdisciplinary Early Childhood Education pursuant to 704 KAR 20:690

Other Quality Standards for Preschool Program:

K.R.S. § 157.3175. 

(1) . . . Administrative regulations shall establish eligibility criteria, program guidelines, and standards for personnel.

(2) "Developmentally appropriate preschool program" means a program which focuses on the physical, intellectual, social, and emotional development of young children. The preschool program shall help children with their interpersonal and socialization skills.

. . . (5) Each program proposal shall include, at a minimum:     

  (a) A description of the process conducted by the district to assure that the parents or guardians of all eligible participants have been made aware of the program and of their right to participate;      

  (b) A description of the planned educational programming and related services;
      
  (c) The estimated number of children participating in the program;      

  (d) Strategies for involving children with disabilities;      

  (e) Estimated ratio of staff to children with the maximum being one (1) adult for each ten (10) children;     

  (f) The estimated percentage of children participating in the program who are at risk of educational failure;
      

  (g) Information on the training and qualifications of program staff and documentation that the staff meet required standards;      

  (h) A budget and per-child expenditure estimate;      

  (i) A plan to facilitate active parental involvement in the preschool program, including provisions for complementary parent education when appropriate;     

  (j) Facilities and equipment which are appropriate for young children;   

  (k) The days of the week and hours of a day during which the program shall operate;

  (l) A plan for coordinating the program with existing medical and social services, including a child development and health screening component;      

  (m) Assurances that participants shall receive breakfast or lunch;      

  (n) Program sites which meet state and local licensure requirements;      

  (o) A plan for coordinating program philosophy and activities with the local district's primary school program . . . . 

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.   

Section 6.  Program Operation.     

  . . . (2) If a double session program is utilized, the following provisions shall be made:


   . . . (d) Maximum number of children assigned to one (1) lead teacher shall be limited to the ratio established in Section 7(4) of this administrative regulation.

   (4) Maximum group size for eligible children shall be twenty (20) children. The staff ratio in the classroom shall consist of one (1) adult for a maximum of ten (10) children pursuant to staff qualifications established in Section 7 of this administrative regulation. Consideration shall be given to increasing the number of staff or decreasing the group size depending upon the needs of the children, including the needs of children with disabilities. An adult shall not be left alone with more than ten (10) preschool children. The local school district shall have a written policy for assistance from another adult if one (1) adult is responsible for a group of children.

   (5) The program shall allow for active parental involvement. Consideration of the different types of family structures, such as the single parent, foster parent and extended family, shall be made when planning activities. At least the following opportunities shall be made available to parents:

   (a) Participation in classroom and other preschool activities as volunteers or observers;

   (b) Parent training, education or other activities which the parent has helped to develop;

   (c) Working with the child in cooperation with preschool staff;

   (d) Meeting with preschool and other appropriate staff regarding the child's individual needs and progress or other two (2) way communication systems developed with the parent; and

   (e) Periodic home visits by preschool staff, with a minimum of two (2) visits per child per year and with the first visit conducted within sixty (60) school days after enrollment.

   (6) To meet the comprehensive needs of children, the program shall collaborate with medical, health, mental health and social service agencies. Information about community services, resources and facilities shall be made available to parents. Program staff shall assist parents in coordinating interagency services for children and families.

   (7) A local school district shall assure through coordination with existing medical and social services that all children participating in the program receive child development and health screening.

   (a) Health screening shall include growth assessment, vision and hearing screening, assessment of current immunization status, and general health status.

   (b) Child development screening shall include screening of gross and fine motor skills, cognitive functioning, communication skills, self-help skills and social-emotional skills.

   (c) Child development screening may be accomplished through various means, including systematic observation in the classroom or other natural setting. Screening results shall not be used for determining placement or planning the curriculum.

   (d) Child development and health screening shall be completed within thirty (30) school days of enrollment by personnel trained in the procedures utilized.

   (e) Contact shall be made with the parent or legal guardian if screening results indicate a need for further assessment by a specialist, follow-up, or referral for special education and related services or other appropriate resources.

   (8) A local school shall assist the parent or legal guardian as needed through cooperation with existing medical and social services to obtain the physical examination required of all children prior to school enrollment.

   . . . (12) The program shall promote physical growth by:

   (a) Providing adequate indoor and outdoor space pursuant to Section 8 of this administrative regulation;

   . . . (d) Providing breakfast or lunch to each eligible child, pursuant to the requirements of the National School Breakfast Program or National School Lunch Program;

   . . . (14) The program shall be individualized to meet the special needs of children by:

   . . . (b) Having staff and program resources reflective of the racial and ethnic population of the children in the program; and

   (c) Providing adaptations for children with special needs.

   (15) The program shall utilize developmentally appropriate materials and equipment as follows:

   (a) Furniture, equipment and materials shall be of sufficient quantity, quality and variety to meet the needs of the children and shall be arranged in a way as to facilitate learning, assure a balanced program of spontaneous and structured activities, and encourage self-reliance in the children. Test sheets, workbooks and ditto sheets shall not be used as they are not developmentally appropriate for preschool children.

   (b) The equipment and materials shall be:

   1. Consistent with the specific educational objectives of the local program;

   2. Consistent with the cultural and ethnic background of the children;

   3. Geared to the age, ability, and developmental needs of the children;

   4. Safe, durable, and kept in good condition;

   5. Stored in a safe and orderly fashion when not in use;

   6. Accessible, attractive, and inviting to the children; and

   7. Designed to provide a variety of learning experiences and to encourage experimentation and exploration.

   (16) Space shall be arranged so that children may work individually, together in small groups, and in a large group. Space shall be arranged to provide clear pathways for children to move from one area to another.

   (17) Centers or areas in the classroom shall include space for activities including art, blockbuilding, cooking, gross motor, housekeeping or dramatic play, language arts or library, manipulative materials, math or problem solving, multimedia, music, science or social studies, and wood working. 

   . . . (19) Children shall not be retained in the preschool program.


   . . . (21) The preschool program shall utilize the local school district's current safety policies regarding accident records, medical emergency plans, fire and disaster plans, first aid, dispensing of medications, and reporting of child abuse and neglect, with modification as needed to accommodate young children.

Section 8.  Facilities and Transportation.

   (1) A preschool program shall operate in compliance with administrative regulations promulgated by the Kentucky Board of Education in areas including facilities, safety, health, and transportation.

   (2) If a program is extended to provide child care before or after the standard operating hours of the preschool program, that portion of the program shall be considered day care and shall meet the standards for day care facilities promulgated by the Cabinet for Families and Children and established in 905 K.A.R. Chapter 2 and 922 K.A.R. Chapter 2.

   (3) A local school district may provide transportation to preschool children. If a local school district transports preschool children, services shall be operated in conformance with administrative regulations pertaining to the transportation of school children, as established in 702 K.A.R. Chapter 5.

  (4) Regardless of whether transportation is provided, a local school district shall make provisions for safe arrival and departure of all children, with a procedure for ensuring that preschool children are released to the parent or a person authorized by the parent.

Delivery of Preschool Services:

K.R.S. § 157.3175.
   
(4) . . . Districts may submit proposals for implementing new services, enhancing existing preschool education services, or contracting for services. In designing a local early childhood education program, each district shall work with existing preschool programs to avoid duplication of programs and services, to avoid supplanting federal funds, and to maximize Head Start funds in order to serve as many four (4) year old children as possible.     

(5) Each program proposal shall include, at a minimum:  

. . . (q) Certification from the Head Start director that the Head Start program is fully utilized pursuant to subsection (4) of this section.

704 K.A.R. § 3:410.


   Section 4. Interagency Agreements. (1) A preschool facility or service provided by a local school district, either directly or by contract or cooperative agreement with another provider, shall meet the requirements of this administrative regulation and all other applicable school laws and administrative regulations.

   (2) A contract or cooperative agreement for operating the preschool program may be negotiated with another school district, another public agency, private school or preschool program. A nonpublic school program providing preschool services shall be approved for that purpose by the Kentucky Board of Education.

   (3) A contract or cooperative agreement shall be in writing and shall include at a minimum the contents set forth in K.R.S. 65.250.

   (4) State preschool funds may be used in a private program if a signed contract or cooperative agreement is on file in the district which documents that:

   (a) The program is separately incorporated from a religious institution;

   (b) The program maintains a nonsectarian board of directors;

   (c) All proceeds and debts are the property of that corporation;

   (d) The program pays reasonable rent; and

   (e) The program's curriculum is not religious in nature.

Requirements for Student Assessment and Program Evaluation:

K.R.S. § 157.3175(5).  Each program proposal shall include, at a minimum:      

 . . . (p) An evaluation component. 

K.A.R. § 3:410.   

Section 6.  Program Operation.
 

  . . . (18) Assessment of children within the preschool program shall be for the purpose of planning activities and evaluating progress, and shall not be used to restrict entry into or exit from the preschool program. The program shall include developmentally appropriate assessment of children which:

   (a) Provides for ongoing observation, recording and evaluation of each child's growth and development for the purpose of planning activities to suit individual needs;

   (b) Is accomplished by observation or activity with the child in familiar structured and informal situations;

   (c) Includes information from parents;

   (d) Is used to inform parents on a regular basis regarding the child's progress in physical, intellectual, communication, social, emotional, intrapersonal, and interpersonal skills and development; and

   (e) considers the cultural background of the child.

   . . . Section 9. Program Evaluation.   

(1) At least annually, parents, staff and other professionals shall be involved in evaluating the local preschool program's effectiveness in meeting the needs of participating children.


(2) The program evaluation shall address:

   (a) Rate of participation by eligible children;

   (b) Parental satisfaction with services provided;

   (c) Success of participating children as they complete the preschool program and progress through the primary school program; and

   (d) Adherence to state administrative regulations on the subject area.

(3) A local school district preschool program shall be subject to evaluation by the Department of Education to determine the effectiveness of the statewide preschool program.


Table of Contents
State Preschool Program
   

Overview

State Policy

Eligibility Criteria

Program Length/Duration

Funding

Quality Standards

Delivery of Preschool Services

Requirements for Student Assessment and Program Evaluation

Legal Framework
   

Education Clause in State Constitution

Summary of Case Law on School Finance System

Summary of Case Law on Preschool

Constitutional Provisions on Public Education
Case Law Digest
   

Is Education a Fundamental Right?

School Finance Cases in Favor of Plaintiffs

Standard for a Constitutionally Adequate Education

School Finance Cases against Plaintiffs

Decisions Ruling School Finance Issues Were Non-Justiciable

Cases Relating to State-Funded Preschool

Pending School Finance Cases

Statutes, Regulations and Guidance Documents
   

Provisions Expressing State Policy on Preschool

Eligibility Criteria

Program Length/Duration

Scope of State's Responsibility to Provide Preschool

Scope of State's Responsibility to Fund Preschool

Source of Funding for Preschool Program

Scope of Child's Right to Attend Preschool

Curriculum Content Standards

Teacher Certification/ Qualification Standards

Other Quality Standards

Delivery of Preschool Services

Requirements for Student Assessment and Program Evaluation

Starting at 3, a project of Education Law Center, is supported by a grant from The Pew Charitable Trusts